Imaging & Pain

In the clinic, we get a lot of questions about pain because it is the main reason people walk through the door.  Today I am going to go through a brief review of pain and imaging. Imaging refers to radiographs (x-rays), MRIs, and CT scans. These are typically used to help a medical provider determine what is causing the pain and the best intervention to resolve the problem.

 

What do we know?

 Numerous imaging studies ranging from the knee to the low back show that the level of pathology cannot predict a person’s pain experience.  We cannot predict pain, the level of disability, or long-term activity based on an image.

 Individuals with chronic low back pain have been compared to those with no back pain.  The findings on the imaging do not show consistent differences between these two samples.  For example, a woman with nasty, limiting pain may show nothing with an x-ray and MRI while a pain-free older woman could have an image that looks like they should be in a wheelchair.  

Another study design uses individuals with no pain.  Radiologists are asked to identify any pathologies in the image without any other information.  Most people will be diagnosed with an identifiable pathology despite having no pain.

Here are a couple of things to consider:

The use of MRI is increasing despite evidence showing it does not improve outcomes. The increase in MRI use has been correlated with the increasing rate of surgical intervention.  This means people are getting a surgery that is not improving long-term outcomes. 

Knowledge of imaging abnormalities, like knowing you have a disc herniation, has been linked with fear avoidance behaviors but not improved long-term outcomes.  This means that you may become afraid of your own body for no reason. It is hard to know what is normal and what is pathological.  90% of 60 years old without low back pain will have a degenerated or bulging disc.  Is this pathological or just normal?  

Imaging is a critical tool that we use in specific situations, but it is rarely the first tool we use in diagnosis. 

When we refer to imaging, we use these guidelines: 

Progressive or severe neurological deficits.  This can include loss of muscle, loss of reflexes, or changes in sensation 

Severe, persistent pain that is not responsive to treatment 

Specific pathologies that can be ruled out with imaging 

History of other non-orthopedic pathology like cancer 

If you think an image is needed, please let us know so we can review the case with you.

 

Related Posts

diagram showing heel pain in Tucson caused by different structures in the foot including the plantar fascia and flexor digitorum brevis

Flexor Digitorum Brevis Pain: 7 Signs Your Heel Pain Isn’t Plantar Fasciitis

Many cases of heel pain diagnosed as plantar fasciitis may actually involve other structures in the foot, especially the flexor digitorum brevis muscle on the bottom of the foot. The article outlines seven key signs that point toward flexor digitorum brevis involvement, including cramping, pain with toe flexion, changes in walking pattern, and worsening symptoms after activity. It emphasizes that proper diagnosis matters because different tissues respond to different treatments, and persistent heel pain often requires a more detailed evaluation than simply labeling it plantar fasciitis.

Read More »

Steps To Develop A Diagnosis In Physical Therapy

“My butt hurts.” A significant proportion of my conversations start with this statement. She continued, “ I have regular active release along with dry needling. I stretch my hamstring ALL THE TIME and I still have pain.” Her frustration was palpable. “I know I have a tight hamstring and there is scar tissue.  But it’s been 8 months.” She assumes the pain must be the hamstring; we call this the pain generator.  The hamstring tendon attaches right where her pain starts. The tightness is over the hamstring muscle belly.  She describes the pain in a clear way that implicates the hamstring.   She made a convincing argument that the hamstring is the issue and the diagnosis has been repeated by multiple medical providers including a physician and two physical therapists. The location matched.  Running increased the pain. Another match. Stretching and manual therapy provided temporary relief. But 8 months into the

Read More »

When and Where You Feel Foot Pain During Walking Is Key for Diagnosis

Why the Phase of Pain Matters Foot pain while walking is one of the most common reasons people seek physical therapy. Understanding when and where it hurts can reveal the true cause. Its actually diagnostic. (If you want to read more about how we think about diagnostics, read How to Find the Real Cause of Pain: Our 4-Pillar Diagnosis Process). This means we can figure out the pain generator. That is a large list. It can be the fat pad, your fascia (the most common, incorrect diagnosis), plantar intrinsics (muscles on the bottom of the foot which is primarily the flexor digitorum brevis, abductor hallucis, and abductor digiti minimi), the flexor hallucis longus, the tibial nerve, the medial or lateral plantar nerve, the calcaneus, the talus, the bones of the midfoot and forefoot, the foot and ankle joints, ligaments, the hallux (big toe), or the little toes. It does not

Read More »
diagram showing heel pain in Tucson caused by different structures in the foot including the plantar fascia and flexor digitorum brevis

Flexor Digitorum Brevis Pain: 7 Signs Your Heel Pain Isn’t Plantar Fasciitis

Many cases of heel pain diagnosed as plantar fasciitis may actually involve other structures in the foot, especially the flexor digitorum brevis muscle on the bottom of the foot. The article outlines seven key signs that point toward flexor digitorum brevis involvement, including cramping, pain with toe flexion, changes in walking pattern, and worsening symptoms after activity. It emphasizes that proper diagnosis matters because different tissues respond to different treatments, and persistent heel pain often requires a more detailed evaluation than simply labeling it plantar fasciitis.

Read More »

Steps To Develop A Diagnosis In Physical Therapy

“My butt hurts.” A significant proportion of my conversations start with this statement. She continued, “ I have regular active release along with dry needling. I stretch my hamstring ALL THE TIME and I still have pain.” Her frustration was palpable. “I know I have a tight hamstring and there is scar tissue.  But it’s been 8 months.” She assumes the pain must be the hamstring; we call this the pain generator.  The hamstring tendon attaches right where her pain starts. The tightness is over the hamstring muscle belly.  She describes the pain in a clear way that implicates the hamstring.   She made a convincing argument that the hamstring is the issue and the diagnosis has been repeated by multiple medical providers including a physician and two physical therapists. The location matched.  Running increased the pain. Another match. Stretching and manual therapy provided temporary relief. But 8 months into the

Read More »

When and Where You Feel Foot Pain During Walking Is Key for Diagnosis

Why the Phase of Pain Matters Foot pain while walking is one of the most common reasons people seek physical therapy. Understanding when and where it hurts can reveal the true cause. Its actually diagnostic. (If you want to read more about how we think about diagnostics, read How to Find the Real Cause of Pain: Our 4-Pillar Diagnosis Process). This means we can figure out the pain generator. That is a large list. It can be the fat pad, your fascia (the most common, incorrect diagnosis), plantar intrinsics (muscles on the bottom of the foot which is primarily the flexor digitorum brevis, abductor hallucis, and abductor digiti minimi), the flexor hallucis longus, the tibial nerve, the medial or lateral plantar nerve, the calcaneus, the talus, the bones of the midfoot and forefoot, the foot and ankle joints, ligaments, the hallux (big toe), or the little toes. It does not

Read More »